BBC Sport’s Chris Bevan examines where it all went wrong for Mick McCarthy and Sunderland this season. The main culprit: expensive signings which simply didn’t pan out:
Sunderland signed 12 players last summer after winning promotion back to the Premiership - including two on loan - for a conservative £4.25m.
But Wigan and West Ham also overhauled their squads in the summer, and without breaking the bank.
Hammers boss Alan Pardew spent £4.8m on nine players before the season began, while Wigan manager Paul Jewell brought in 11 players for £5.95m.
West Ham only loosened the purse strings in the January transfer window when their top flight status was secured, spending £7.25m on Dean Ashton.
At the same time Wigan splashed £2m on Paul Scharner, while McCarthy’s only action was to bring in Rory Delap from Southampton and Kevin Smith from Leeds, both on free transfers.
[…]
Jon Stead, Andy Gray, Daryl Murphy and Anthony Le Tallec have all struggled to make an impact in the Premiership, scoring just three goals between them all season - and all four were close-season McCarthy signings.
Stead (£1.8m) has not scored at all and Gray (£1.1m) has managed only one.
Stephen Elliott and Marcus Stewart got the goals to win promotion last season, but Elliott has been injured for long spells and the experienced Stewart left for Bristol City in the summer.
£1.25m goalkeeper Kelvin Davis hasn’t distinguished himself either, though there’s only so much you can do behind that defence. Poor Mick ends his Premiership career with a record for futility which may never be broken: 2-4-31.
Damian P.